Missing SADB_X_EXT_ in kernel_pfkey plugin for FreeBSD
There is some SADB_X_EXT_ missing in the kernel_pfkey plugin when under FreeBSD. It's not really an issue since everything is working correctly.
However when the verbose is enabled and we receive a SADB_X_EXT_SA_REPLAY extension, a crash can occur.
We patched kernel_pfkey_kernel.c with the missing extensions and it fixed our issue.
#1 Updated by Tobias Brunner 10 months ago
- Tracker changed from Issue to Bug
- Status changed from New to Feedback
- Target version set to 5.8.2
The dependency on constants and structs defined in a platform-specific header file is definitely not ideal. However, we don't use most of the structs (and those we do are portable or inside ifdefs), so this is mainly an issue with the strings for the debug messages. The crash comes from the fact that
SADB_EXT_MAX is used in the
ENUM() call, which might be larger than the last constant we actually have a string for. Using a different constant is tricky as compilation fails if the header doesn't define it. But I think we can at least fix the crash and just print the numeric identifier for unknown identifiers.
Regarding adding additional structs/strings, I had a look at the different headers. Linux, FreeBSD and macOS are the same up to
SADB_X_EXT_SA2 (19), then macOS diverges. FreeBSD and Linux do so after
SADB_X_EXT_NAT_T_DPORT (22), as you already noticed. FreeBSD and macOS might share 27/28 again (address migration), although it looks like macOS might use its own message and not
SADB_UPDATE for this, so that is probably without consequence. OpenBSD uses a completely different set of custom extensions, but strongSwan currently doesn't run on it, so I guess we can ignore that for now.
Anyway, adding the strings should be OK, however, adding structs could be tricky when compiling on older versions of a platform whose headers don't yet include that struct, so that requires some ifdefs.
I pushed two commits to the 3210-pfkey-ext branch.
#3 Updated by Tobias Brunner 10 months ago
I tested the 3210-pfkey-ext branch and it worked fine. Thank you.
Thanks for testing. I've now replaced the runtime check with one that should be evaluated during compilation (which already revealed several missing strings in our codebase). Does that still work for you (the FreeBSD build on Cirrus-CI was successful, so I'm hopeful :)?